Creamy Cheesy Potato Soup (Stove Top, Instant Pot, or Slow Cooker)

This recipe for creamy cheesy potato soup is sponsored by Rico’s. All opinions are my own.

Warm up with a big batch of this cheddar cheese potato soup. It’s packed full of hearty red potatoes and creamy cheddar cheese sauce!

It’s finally starting to feel like soup weather around here and I am taking full advantage by making as many soups as I can. Not only is it a filling and frugal way to feed your family but soup is so versatile!

I love that this creamy cheesy potato soup is filled with just a few ingredients that simmer into a thick and creamy potato soup. Serve it with a crusty bread or in a bread bowl and you are all set with a warm-you-up meal. You can make this soup on your stove top, slow cooker, or instant pot!

Which potatoes to use?

I use red potatoes in this recipe and I do not take the skins off. This is a personal preference. I like that it adds a bit of color to the soup. The skins blend up nicely but do add some pops of red to this cheesy soup.

If you would rather have the skins peeled, you totally can. It does not change the cook time at all.

Ingredients in creamy cheesy potato soup

1. Red potatoes
2. Vegetable broth
3. Rico’s Premium Cheddar Cheese Sauce
4. garlic powder
5. onion powder
6. oregano
7. salt
8. pepper

Converting to a slow cooker or instant pot recipe

You can absolutely make creamy cheesy potato soup in your slow cooker or pressure cooker.

For the slow cooker:

Combine all of the ingredients, except for the cheese. Cook on low 4-6 hours. Blend up the soup as directed. Mix in the cheese, cover, and let cook for another 30 minutes.

For the Instant Pot:

Combine all ingredients, except for the cheese. Cook on high pressure for 10 minutes. Blend up the soup as directed. Turn your pot to saute and mix in the cheddar cheese sauce. Let simmer 10 minutes and serve.

The Cheese Sauce Used for Cheesy Potato Soup

We use Rico’s Premium Cheddar Cheese Sauce for this recipe. If you haven’t cooked with Rico’s products before, you are in for a treat. We love cooking with Rico’s because it is an easy way to add an extra layer of flavor to favorite dishes.

Their cheese sauces are so versatile, you can use them for a queso recipe, nacho dish, holiday casserole, side dish, or entree (like this taco casserole). We found our Rico’s Premium Cheddar Cheese Sauce at Walmart.

Serve this in Italian Bread Bowls

You may also like:

• Broccoli Cheese Soup
• Pressure Cooker Vegetable Beef Soup
• Slow Cooker Creamy Chicken Pot Pie Soup with Biscuits

We love warming up with a big batch of soup on cold nights and this creamy cheesy potato soup works perfectly!